First Business JournalFirst Business Journal
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    First Business JournalFirst Business Journal
    Subscribe
    • Home
    • NC News

      How Small Businesses Drive Economic Growth in North Carolina and Beyond

      April 7, 2023

      Why Job Openings Still Outnumber Available Workers

      March 9, 2023

      Women in Business: How Their Skills Benefit the Economy

      February 28, 2023

      Panasonic Closes Business Phone Division: Future Uncertain

      February 12, 2023

      Collins Aerospace closing West Point facility in Winston-Salem

      February 2, 2023
    • SC News

      Update on 2 found dead inside Simpsonville home

      February 2, 2023

      Where is the snow this winter?

      February 1, 2023

      Former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley expected to announce presidential run: Sources

      February 1, 2023

      NASH to Build Mixed-Use Property Within Nexton Development in Summerville, South Carolina

      January 31, 2023

      South Carolina State releases its 2023 schedule

      January 31, 2023
    • Business Ideas and Tips

      The 4 Most Important Business Expenses to Watch

      July 25, 2023

      20 Ways to Create Customer Value » Succeed As Your Own Boss

      July 24, 2023

      10 Signs Your Side Hustle Will Be a Success

      July 22, 2023

      Collaborative Selling with Carole Mahoney » Succeed As Your Own Boss

      July 21, 2023

      A Primer for Business Owners

      July 21, 2023
    • Sales & Marketing

      10 Action Plan Examples: Strategies for Success

      July 17, 2023

      Small Business Action Plans: The Catalyst for Success

      July 10, 2023

      Meeting Customer Expectations: Importance, Strategies to Exceed Them, and Management Tips

      July 6, 2023

      Mission Statement Vs. Vision Statement: How They Differ

      July 3, 2023

      Writing the Perfect Mission Statement: A Guide to Success

      June 27, 2023
    • Solving Business problems

      On the Cutting Edge: The World’s Latest Mobile Phone Innovations

      July 23, 2023

      Why Quality Content is Essential For your Website

      July 23, 2023

      What Do Process Servers Do?

      July 22, 2023

      Will a Personal Loan Help With Your Credit Score?

      July 22, 2023

      5-Steps to Attracting Only Dream Clients

      July 21, 2023
    First Business JournalFirst Business Journal
    Home»NC News»NC lawsuit on political power hampered by lost emails, delayed by procedure, lawyers say
    NC News

    NC lawsuit on political power hampered by lost emails, delayed by procedure, lawyers say

    SiteadminBy SiteadminNovember 20, 2022No Comments7 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Telegram Pinterest Tumblr Reddit WhatsApp Email
    court-gavel-01-DMID1-5saunuu2l-640x480.jpg
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    Until last week, a high-profile lawsuit questioning the legitimacy of two state constitutional amendments had been bogged down in procedural issues for months, raising new concerns over political gamesmanship in the state’s judicial system. was rising.

    The lawsuit is also hampered by an email retention policy that changed last year. This could ultimately mean that the state attorney of record that the NAACP hoped to consider in litigation no longer exists.

    Procedural issues came to a head Tuesday when NAACP lawyers asked the North Carolina Supreme Court to take the case to lower court, claiming a panel of Republican judges unnecessarily delayed the case. On Wednesday, the panel independently proceeded, discussing the Supreme Court’s request and proceeding with the case again.

    Attorneys may not currently have access to lawmakers’ records for the 2017 and 2018 debates at issue in this case. Generally, lawmakers’ e-mails are automatically deleted after three years. policies implemented last year, The changes lawyers had predicted would affect many lengthy legal battles over laws passed by the state legislature.

    These types of lawsuits are common in North Carolina and often last for years.

    Brooks Fuller, director of the North Carolina Public Government Commission, said:

    Legislative Services Director Paul Coble, who oversees the day-to-day operations of the Capitol and implemented the policy, did not respond to a request for comment last week. But he has defended the policy in the past, saying states shouldn’t pay for server space to store legislative records indefinitely. He said he could keep the records as long as he wanted or ask Congress to keep them for up to 10 years.

    But a lawyer representing the NAACP says he has spoken to lawmakers who appear unfamiliar with the policy. They also say Coble’s office took a detour when it was looking for emails related to Congressional debate on the state’s income tax cap.

    After contacting the State Archives, the Legislature’s Financial Research Division, Coble’s office, and individual and former legislators, no records appear to exist, said an attorney with the Southern Environmental Law Center, which represents the NC NAACP. . case.

    SELC Attorney Brooks Rainey Pearson said:

    lawsuit

    The underlying lawsuit, NAACP v. Moore, argued that the Republican overwhelming majority in Congress in 2018 could not have started the process of amending the state constitution because the state legislature was illegally occupying seats. claim. The legislators had been drawn from districts later declared unconstitutional gerrymandering in a separate lawsuit. The NAACP lawsuit argues that the Republican majority can pass ordinary bills but cannot bring constitutional amendments to the voters.

    As the lawsuit progressed, the issue was narrowed down to two voter-approved amendments in the 2018 election. One is lowering the cap on state income tax rates and the other is requiring photo ID to vote.

    A High Court judge agreed with the NAACP’s arguments, and Republicans appealed. Panel of three Appeals Court Judges In 2020, he sided with Republican lawmakers. However, in August the state Supreme Court split. He said the amendment could be scrapped. Because Democratic justices on the Superior Court outnumbered Republican justices, the case was remanded to the state Superior Court for further discussion.

    But before the Superior Court could hold these claims, the Court of Appeals had to formally remand the case. That didn’t happen, and the NAACP legal team filed a Mandams warrant in the Supreme Court this week, seeking to get the Court of Appeals to take action.

    “It’s been months since this case has been in limbo,” said SELC’s Kym Meyer, the lead attorney on the case. “nothing [the Court of Appeals] decide. They literally just sign a piece of paper and send it in. ”

    The documents were filed Wednesday, the day after Meyer and other attorneys sought enforcement action in the Supreme Court. So their request for a warrant was dismissed Thursday as moot.

    The Court of Appeals Committee is made up of three Republican justices. Chief Justice Donna Stroud, Justices Chris Dillon and Jeff Carpenter. They declined to comment through a court system spokesman who said the judge would not comment on the ongoing case.

    Battle of the Partisans?

    Meyer said he would not “make assumptions about what is going on.”

    But process, timing, and partisanship are at issue in many high-profile cases as they move up and down the North Carolina court system. 4 to 3 Democrat majority. The Court of Appeals is dominated by Republicans, 11 to 4 for her.

    State High Court Administration Flip in January When the new judges elected earlier this month take their seats. At that point, Republicans could retain her 5-to-2 margin in court and decide important issues that are different than they are in court today.
    Republicans said last year that high-profile cases skipped the appeals court and went straight to the state supreme court, speeding cases on education funding, voter identification, redistricting, and felony voting rights. I shouted foul. According to News & Observer. Some Republicans openly questioned the court’s Democratic majority’s rush to end the case before the November election.

    This time, it’s the left who fears a Republican commission is holding the case pending, perhaps until the Republican-leaning Supreme Court takes over.

    Email

    Meyer said his attorney failed to initiate discovery when the NAACP case was first presented to a High Court judge. Specific situation details.

    But the Supreme Court decision called for new discoveries of fact and created new needs for evidence. This could include legislative emails that are over 3 years old and would have been deleted over 3 years ago. New email policy. The NAACP legal team already had a lot of information about the Voter Identification Amendment. What they are now looking for is “information behind the thinking on tax cap revisions,” Rainie Pearson said.

    As such, it is important to communicate with Coble offices as to who is the actual custodian of those records and who is responsible for retaining and providing them under state public records laws or as part of the legal discovery process. This led to the exchange of A series of emails provided by The Southern Environmental Law Center show Rainey Pearson going from person to person in search of information.

    Congress’ email policy, announced last year as a storage space saver, allows legislators to select emails to be archived on state servers for up to 10 years, and to retrieve emails from state servers. They say they can keep their emails longer if they do. Coble says it ultimately comes down to individual lawmakers if they want to keep the emails for more than three years.

    SELC’s email chain shows that at least some current and former lawmakers were unaware of the new policy. Former state senator Andrew Bullock, who left Congress in 2017 and at one point served as co-chair of the Senate’s Tax Policy Making Committee, remembers how long Laney Pearson asked, but has no record. Said he didn’t have one. , according to an email reviewed by WRAL News.

    “All my mail was on the NCGA servers,” Brock wrote. “I thought they were backed up and should be available.”

    Brock told WRAL News Congress may need to reconsider its email policy, but lawmakers receive hundreds of emails a day. Of those, 170 of them either resign or are not re-elected, so there is a slight turnover each year. “That’s a lot of stuff you have to store,” Bullock said.

    Fuller, director of the Open Government Commission, said the apparent confusion was “just a call for clarification” and that the archiving process needed improvement and that the situation was likely to repeat itself. rice field.

    “Rather than trying to clean up the mess, we should invest in public records programs that keep public records as long as possible,” he said. “Because on the day the record was created, we don’t know if the record is really relevant to any meaningful litigation.”

    delayed Emails hampered lawsuit Lawyers lost political power procedure
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Telegram Email
    Previous ArticleCharges dismissed for ex-Horry County, South Carolina deputy who was passenger in van drowning case
    Next Article How to Master Government Bidding as a Small Business Owner
    Siteadmin
    • Website

    Related Posts

    How To Maximize The Power Of Newsletters

    May 19, 2023

    The Power of Connection To Create Memorable Pitches

    May 10, 2023

    How Small Businesses Drive Economic Growth in North Carolina and Beyond

    April 7, 2023
    Add A Comment

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Newsletter

    Subscribe my Newsletter for new blog posts, tips & new photos. Let's stay updated!

    Categories
    • Business Ideas and Tips (375)
    • Business PODCAST (1)
    • Industry Trends (4)
    • NC News (190)
    • Sales & Marketing (49)
    • SC News (192)
    • Solving Business problems (307)
    • Uncategorized (1)
    Copyright ©️ All rights reserved. | First Business Journal
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • GDPR Policy
    • Disclaimer

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

    You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings.

    First Business Journal
    Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

    Strictly Necessary Cookies

    Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

    If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.